Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
2012, Ethnography
Infrastructural practices, made by the manipulations of pumps, pipes and hydraulic expertise, play a critical role in managing urban populations. Drawing on two years of ethnographic research in Mumbai, in this article I show how Muslim settlers in a northern suburb are being rendered abject residents of the city. Abjection isn’t not a lack of social and political entitlements, but a denial of them. As Muslim settlers are being pushed down to claim less desirable water through the deliberate inaction of city engineers and technocrats, this article shows the iterative process through which abjection is made through tenuous and contentious infrastructural connections between the government and the governed.
In Hydraulic City, Nikhil Anand explores the politics of Mumbai's water infrastructure to demonstrate how citizenship emerges through the continuous efforts to control, maintain, and manage the city's water. Through extensive ethnographic fieldwork in Mumbai's settlements, Anand found that Mumbai's water flows, not through a static collection of pipes and valves, but through a dynamic infrastructure built on the relations between residents, plumbers, politicians, engineers, and the 3,000 miles of pipe that bind them. In addition to distributing water, the public water network often reinforces social identities and the exclusion of marginalized groups, as only those actively recognized by city agencies receive legitimate water services. This form of recognition—what Anand calls "hydraulic citizenship"—is incremental, intermittent, and reversible. It provides residents an important access point through which they can make demands on the state for other public services such as sanitation and education. Tying the ways Mumbai's poorer residents are seen by the state to their historic, political, and material relations with water pipes, the book highlights the critical role infrastructures play in consolidating civic and social belonging in the city.
Economic and Political Weekly
Quest for water: Muslims at Mumbai's Periphery2012 •
An ethnography of everyday life in Shivaji Nagar, a predominantly Muslim slum locality in Mumbai, illustrates how its "Muslimness" complicates the residents' access to water, a commodified and politicised amenity. The struggles of local Muslims to access water also involve holding the state accountable through localised "mundane" politics at the periphery. The state's inability to address the differential access to water is challenged through locally elected political representatives. The paper also explores the role of "intermediaries" who are accused of being the "water mafia" by the state and the English media and argues that they play an important role in making the state accessible through acts of subversion and collaboration.
CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY, Vol. 26, Issue 4, pp. 542–564. ISSN 0886-7356, online ISSN 1548-1360. C 2011 by the American Anthropological Association. All rights reserved. DOI: 10.1111/j.1548-1360.2011.01111.x
PRESSURE: The Politechnics of water supply in Mumbai by Nikhil AnandIn Mumbai, most all residents are delivered their daily supply of water for a few hours every day, on a water supply schedule. Subject to a more precarious supply than the city’s upper-class residents, the city’s settlers have to consistently demand that their water come on “time” and with “pressure.” Taking pressure seriously as both a social and natural force, in this article I focus on the ways in which settlers mobilize the pressures of politics, pumps, and pipes to get water. I show how these practices not only allow settlers to live in the city, but also produce what I call hydraulic citizenship—a form of belonging to the city made by effective political and technical connections to the city’s infrastructure. Yet, not all settlers are able to get water from the city water department. The outcomes of settlers’ efforts to access water depend on a complex matrix of socionatural relations that settlers make with city engineers and their hydraulic infrastructure. I show how these arrangements describe and produce the cultural politics of water in Mumbai. By focusing on the ways in which residents in a predominantly Muslim settlement draw water despite the state’s neglect, I conclude by pointing to the indeterminacy of water, and the ways in which its seepage and leakage make different kinds of politics and publics possible in the city.
Cultural Anthropology
Pressure: The PoliTechnics of Water Supply in Mumbai2011 •
In Mumbai, most all residents are delivered their daily supply of water for a few hours every day, on a water supply schedule. Subject to a more precarious supply than the city’s upper-class residents, the city’s settlers have to consistently demand that their w ater come on “time” and with “pressure. ” T aking pressure seriously as both a social and natural force, in this article I focus on the ways in which settlers mobilize the pressures of politics, pumps, and pipes to get water. I show how these practices not only allow settlers to live in the city, but also produce what I call hydraulic citizenship—a form of belonging to the city made by effective political and technical connections to the city’s infrastructure. Yet, not all settlers are able to get water from the city water department. The outcomes of settlers’ efforts to access water depend on a complex matrix of socionatural relations that settlers make with city engineers and their hydraulic infrastructure. I show how these arrangements describe and produce the cultural politics of water in Mumbai. By focusing on the ways in which residents in a predominantly Muslim settlement draw water despite the state’s neglect, I conclude by pointing to the indeterminacy of water, and the ways in which its seepage and leakage make different kinds of politics and publics possible in the city.
American Ethnologist
Review of "Pipe Politics, Contested Waters: Embedded Infrastructures of Millennial Mumbai" by Lisa Björkman2016 •
Infrastructure has been a somewhat recent revelation in anthropology. Urban ethnographers have long analyzed cities from the ground up; now many are viewing them from the entrails out. This approach is on exacting display in Lisa Björkman's account of the flows and stoppages of water in Mumbai's M-East Ward. What, she asks, is the relationship between the marketization of water in an era of economic liberalization and the actually existing material networks and social processes of water distribution? And what kind of politics does this distribution produce? As Björkman explains early on, Mumbai does not have a water shortage, nor does its sewage department have insufficient funds; rather, its distribution is erratic in both rich and poor neighborhoods. Hers is not a simple story of the lawn mowering of a city by global investment capital, nor is it a celebration of urban informality or resistance politics in the face of planned, state-led modernity. Rather, drawing on Karl Polanyi's notion of embedded markets, Björkman seeks to address Mumbai's changing built space by deciphering water networks and markets for what they are and not viewing them as parables of something else. The central structures in Björkman's tale are the pipes—who controls them, who monitors them, where they go and at what elevation. This book shows how infrastructure itself becomes a site for politics, which Björkman reveals in her granular analysis of how water moves in the city. She describes pipe politics as " the new arenas of contestation " in the business, brokerage, secondary markets, and sociopolitical networks around water distribution vis-à-vis the project to remake Mumbai into a world-class city (3). Central to pipe politics is the question of land, a puzzle that Björkman identifies as a need to reconcile soaring land values with social projects such as infrastructure. This leads us to the book's metanarrative on the world-class city, specifically, how to square the imperative to attract global investment capital with the needs of the local citizenry. Björkman challenges the neat boundaries of this narrative by documenting the regimes of knowledge and authority that water inhabits and tracking the way flows are configured
South Asia-journal of South Asian Studies
Pipe Politics, Contested Waters: Embedded Infrastructures of Millennial Mumbai, by Lisa Björkman2017 •
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
THE ENGINEER AND THE PLUMBER: Mediating Mumbai’s Conflicting Infrastructural Imaginaries2018 •
Two decades ago, the rules governing the provision of piped municipal water supply in Mumbai became linked to the policy frameworks governing eligibility for a property titling scheme. This article outlines the ideological basis and practical implications of the shift, as well as the contradictions of the new regulatory regime. The article demonstrates how these contradictions have been mediated by the material and practical knowledge, embodied expertise, local authority and wide-ranging socio-political work of two sets of actors: municipal water engineers and a cast of characters known locally as 'plumbers'. The social, political and hydraulic imaginaries animating the work of 'plumbing' are bound up with a temporal and spatial imaginary distinctly at odds with the network-flow conception of hydraulic engineering within which the work of water supply planning and distribution in Mumbai is conceptualized, materialized and institutionalized. The hydraulic and legal contradictions of these clashing infrastructural idioms––of flow and event––have rendered the regulatory framework highly unstable. These contradictions eventually erupted in Mumbai's waterscape, leaving the city's water infrastructures suspended in a highly politicized state of limbo between dueling infrastructural imaginaries.
Environment and planning. A
Landscapes of disaster: water, modernity, and urban fragmentation in Mumbai2008 •
Water Alternatives
Urban planning, water provisioning and infrastructural violence at public housing resettlement sites in Ahmedabad, India2018 •
This paper examines the links between urban planning and the politics of water provisioning and violence and conflict in people’s lives by drawing upon research in a low-income locality in Ahmedabad, India. By focusing on public housing sites constructed to resettle poor and low-income residents displaced from central and intermediate areas of the city for urban development projects, the paper looks beyond poor, informal neighbourhoods to explore the dynamics of water provisioning and inequalities in the city. A close examination of the water infrastructure at the sites and their everyday workings is undertaken in order to unravel the socio-material configurations which constitute inadequate water flows, and the ways in which urban planning, policies and governance produce infrastructural violence at the sites. It also traces the various forms of water-related deprivations, burdens, inequities, tensions and conflicts that emerge in people’s lives as a result of their practices in the context of this infrastructural violence.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Becoming a Slum: from Municipal Colony to Illegal Settlement in Liberalization-Era Mumbai2013 •
2014 •
Ethics and Social Welfare
Citizens and 'Squatters': The Contested Subject of Public Policy in Neoliberal Mumbai2013 •
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Ponds, Power and Institutions: The Everyday Governance of Accessing Urban Water Bodies in a Small Bengali CityEnvironment and Planning D: Society and Space
Negotiating states of water: Producing illegibility, bureaucratic arbitrariness, and distributive injustices in DelhiGeoforum
Re)Conceptualizing water inequality in Delhi, India through a feminist political ecology framework2011 •
Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction
The Flaky Accretions of Infrastructure: Sociotechnical Systems, Citizenship, and the Water Supply2021 •
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Governing the Contaminated City: Infrastructure and Sanitation in Colonial and Post-Colonial Bombay2008 •
Journal of Migration Affairs
Migrants Fighting for Water Rights: Sangam Vihar and Deoli, Delhi2021 •